The carbon tax in Canada is a federal policy that charges for carbon emissions from fossil fuels like gasoline and natural gas, aiming to reduce pollution. It started at $20 per tonne in 2019 and is now $80 per tonne in 2024, with plans to reach $170 by 2030. This tax increases the cost of energy, which affects various sectors.
The carbon tax adds about 18.4 cents per litre to gasoline, increasing fuel costs. This raises shipping prices as trucks and delivery services pass on higher fuel costs, leading to more expensive groceries and goods. Retail businesses face higher heating bills, which can increase prices for consumers. Farmers, using diesel for machinery, see higher production costs, contributing to higher food prices. A Fraser Institute study shows industries like manufacturing and agriculture face significant cost increases, often passed to consumers.
The Canada Carbon Rebate returns about 90% of revenues to households, with extra for rural areas. However, for those using more energy, like rural families or frequent drivers, the rebate may not cover increased costs. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) notes small businesses pay 40% of the tax but get only 5% back in rebates, adding to their burden. Studies suggest lower-income households might benefit, but high-energy users often don’t, especially with the tax set to rise. The rebate only includes the direct cost of the tax on Canadians, when counting all the other cost increases nearly everyone receiving the rebate is in the red.
Canada’s carbon tax, implemented as part of the federal government’s strategy to combat climate change, has been a contentious policy, particularly among conservative circles.
The carbon tax, part of Canada’s broader carbon pricing framework, applies to the purchase and use of fossil fuels, covering approximately 80% of the country’s greenhouse gas emissions. It began at $20 per tonne of CO2 equivalent in 2019, rising to $80 per tonne by April 1, 2024, with a planned increase to $170 per tonne by 2030. This policy aims to incentivize reduced emissions by making fossil fuels more expensive, encouraging a shift to cleaner technologies.
The carbon tax directly increases the cost of fossil fuels. For instance, burning one litre of gasoline produces about 2.3 kg of CO2, or 0.0023 tonnes. At $80 per tonne, this adds approximately 18.4 cents per litre to gasoline prices. Similarly, diesel and natural gas face comparable increases, raising the cost of energy for consumers and businesses.
Higher fuel costs directly impact transportation, a critical component of the supply chain. Trucks, ships, and planes, reliant on fossil fuels, see increased operating costs. For example, a delivery truck using 50 litres of diesel per day faces an additional $9.20 in carbon tax costs daily at current rates. These costs are often passed on to consumers, increasing the price of goods like groceries. A National Post article notes that high fuel prices have historically influenced grocery prices, though the impact varies.
Retail businesses, particularly those with large premises, face higher heating costs due to the carbon tax on natural gas. For instance, a study by the Fraser Institute highlights that electric power generation and distribution, crucial for retail operations, could see production cost increases of over 5% with a $50 per tonne tax, a figure likely higher at $80 per tonne. These costs may lead to higher prices for consumer goods, affecting affordability.
Agriculture is another sector heavily impacted. Farmers use diesel for tractors and natural gas for drying grains or heating barns, both subject to the carbon tax. A study analyzing the impact on food prices found that the carbon tax can increase food prices, with Quebec and Alberta most affected, especially if agriculture sectors are not exempt. Higher production costs can contribute to inflation in food prices, a concern for Canadian households already facing affordability challenges.
Energy-intensive industries like manufacturing face significant cost increases. The Fraser Institute’s analysis shows that sectors such as petroleum and coal product manufacturing, agricultural chemical manufacturing, and primary metal manufacturing could see production cost increases of over 1% to 5%, depending on the tax rate. These cost increases can reduce competitiveness, potentially leading to job losses or higher prices for manufactured goods.
The federal government returns carbon tax revenues primarily through the Canada Carbon Rebate, with about 90% going to individuals and families, and the rest to farmers, small businesses, and Indigenous communities. The rebate is designed to be revenue-neutral, with payments based on household size and location, including a 20% rural supplement.
However, there are concerns about its adequacy. For instance, the CFIB reports that small businesses pay about 40% of the carbon tax but receive only 5% back in rebates, down from 9% previously, adding to their operational costs. This discrepancy is particularly burdensome for small businesses, which lack the scale to absorb such costs.
For households, while lower and middle-income families may receive more in rebates than they pay, high-energy users, such as rural families or those with long commutes, may find the rebate insufficient. A CBC News tool allows households to calculate their costs versus rebates, showing variability based on energy consumption. For example, in Saskatchewan, where energy use is high due to cold climates, the estimated yearly cost per household was $946 in 2022, with rebates varying by family size.
Several factors contribute to the perception that Canadians aren’t getting their money back: Households with higher energy consumption, such as those in rural areas or with larger families, may pay more in carbon tax than they receive in rebates. The fixed rebate amount doesn’t scale with energy use, leaving a gap for these groups. As noted by CFIB, small businesses, which employ a significant portion of Canadians, face increased costs without adequate compensation. For example, a business with 10 employees in Saskatchewan received $11,560 in rebates for 2019-2023, but their carbon tax burden could be much higher given their energy use. While the Bank of Canada estimates the carbon tax adds 0.15 percentage points to inflation, conservative critics argue this still contributes to rising living costs, especially when combined with global factors like oil price surges. A Fraser Institute commentary suggests the carbon tax could increase food prices by 3% at $50 per tonne, a figure likely higher now.
While most revenues are rebated, some are used for climate action programs, which conservatives may view as funding “excessive liberal experiments” rather than directly offsetting costs for taxpayers. For instance, Budget 2024 proposed returning $2.5 billion to small businesses, but delays and taxation issues have caused discontent. Less than 1% of the $22B in federal carbon tax revenues have been returned to small businesses, and the cost is going up again on April 1.
The carbon tax, while aimed at environmental goals, imposes significant economic costs on Canadians, increasing prices across various sectors and disproportionately affecting high-energy users and small businesses. While the rebate system attempts to mitigate these costs, it often falls short, particularly for those most impacted by higher energy prices. As the tax is set to rise, it’s imperative to reassess its economic impact and ensure a fairer distribution of rebates to protect Canadian households and businesses from undue financial strain.
- [British Columbia's Carbon Tax detailed explanation](https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/environment/climate-change/clean-economy/carbon-tax)
- [Carbon pricing in Canada comprehensive overview](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_pricing_in_Canada)
- [Carbon content of gasoline per litre scientific calculation](https://www.driverknowledgetests.com/resources/why-does-burning-1-litre-of-fuel-create-over-2kg-of-carbon-dioxide/)
- [How carbon pricing works official government guide](https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/climate-change/pricing-pollution-how-it-will-work/putting-price-on-carbon-pollution.html)
- [Canada Carbon Rebate for individuals eligibility and payments](https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/child-family-benefits/canada-carbon-rebate.html)
- [10 Myths about Carbon Pricing in Canada economic analysis](https://ecofiscal.ca/10-myths-about-carbon-pricing-in-canada/)
- [It’s time to end Canada’s carbon tax! CFIB advocacy](https://www.cfib-fcei.ca/en/site/time-fix-canada-broken-carbon-tax)
- [Carbon pricing and its impact on Canadians clean energy perspective](https://cleanenergycanada.org/carbon-pricing-and-its-impact-on-canadians/)
- [Canada’s carbon pricing explained environmental advocacy](https://davidsuzuki.org/what-you-can-do/carbon-pricing-explained/)
- [Carbon Tax Rebate details for businesses CFIB resource](https://www.cfib-fcei.ca/en/tools-resources/carbon-tax-rebate)
- [Carbon pricing is not to blame for Canada’s affordability challenges policy analysis](https://policyoptions.irpp.org/magazines/december-2023/carbon-price-affordability/)
- [Canada Carbon Rebate amounts for 2024-25 official announcement](https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2024/02/canada-carbon-rebate-amounts-for-2024-25.html)
- [Your Canada Carbon Tax Rebate Explained by Province consumer guide](https://www.canadadrives.ca/blog/news/carbon-taxes-and-carbon-tax-rebates-in-canada-explained)
- [How do your federal carbon tax costs compare to your rebates? CBC calculator](https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/cbc-federal-carbon-tax-calculator-2023-24-year-65-dollars-per-tonne-1.6891467)
- [The Impact of the Federal Carbon Tax on the Competitiveness of Canadian Industries economic study](https://www.fraserinstitute.org/studies/impact-of-the-federal-carbon-tax-on-the-competitiveness-of-canadian-industries)
- [The impact of the carbon tax on Canadian industry Fraser Institute blog](https://www.fraserinstitute.org/blogs/impact-of-the-carbon-tax-on-canadian-industry)
- [How much is the carbon tax to blame for spiking food costs in Canada? media analysis](https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/carbon-tax-groceries-food-prices)
- [The Impact of Carbon Tax on Food Prices and Consumption in Canada academic research](https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/275913/?ln=en)
- [Government policies help push grocery prices higher in Canada Fraser Institute commentary](https://www.fraserinstitute.org/commentary/government-policies-help-push-grocery-prices-higher-canada)
- [Carbon pricing impact on inflation 'quite small': BoC governor news report](https://www.ctvnews.ca/climate-and-environment/carbon-pricing-accounts-for-0-15-percentage-points-of-inflation-boc-governor-says-1.6554273)
- [Less than 1% of the $22B in federal carbon tax revenues have been returned to small businesses CFIB news](https://www.cfib-fcei.ca/en/media/less-than-1-of-the-22b-in-federal-carbon-tax-revenues-have-been-returned-to-small-businesses)
- [Canada Carbon Rebate for Small Businesses Payment Amounts 2019-20 to 2023-24 official data](https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2024/10/canada-carbon-rebate-for-small-businesses-payment-amounts-2019-20-to-2023-24.html)
Comments